Tag: salary scale design

A diverse group of four people gathers around a laptop in an office setting, smiling and engaged. One woman uses a wheelchair. Plants and office supplies are visible in the background. Workplace Equity

EQUITY IN ACTION: ENSURE FAIRNESS ACROSS HR

Written by Noel Madolid on . Posted in Resources.

We’ve all heard the buzzwords: diversity, equity, inclusion. But how many organizations walk the walk when it comes to equity in managing their organization? It’s time to move beyond theoretical discussions and translate those well-intentioned conversations into concrete actions. 

Our “Equity in Action” series explored the building blocks of a truly equitable workplace, from establishing the equivalent worth of jobs and developing a grading structure to utilizing salary surveys and implementing a salary scale and fair pay management mechanisms. In this final installment, we’ll share how your organization can embed equity into every facet of its HR program, whether it’s recruiting new talent or planning for your successors.  

The key is a unified and objective approach to assessing employee skills and capabilities throughout the entire employee lifecycle. Think of standardized processes, clear metrics, and tools that evaluate employees based on their work. This blog post will share how you can integrate equity into your HR functions, ensuring fairness in every stage of a staff member’s journey. 

The challenge of subjectivity and flexibility 

For far too long, HR processes have been marred by subjective assessments. This approach not only hampers the quest for equality but also exacerbates inequality when each HR function is handled on a case-by-case basis. 

Are performance evaluations based on objective criteria, or are some staff members given more leeway than others? Is career advancement based solely on merit and potential, or do personal relationships and “gut feelings” come into play? Are all employees given equal access to training and development programs, or are specific individuals favored? 

These subjective and flexible approaches can create an uneven playing field, where some staff members are inadvertently given an advantage while others are held back. 

To counteract this, organizations need to shift toward a standardized, objective, and consistent approach to evaluating skills and competencies. This involves: 

  • Establishing clear criteria and metrics. Define what success looks like for each grade level and use these objective measures to assess their contributions and performance. 
  • Implementing standardized evaluation processes. Use the same tools and framework for all staff members in similar roles to ensure consistency and fairness. 
  • Providing regular and transparent feedback. Give staff members clear, actionable feedback based on objective data to help them understand their strengths and areas for development. 

By removing subjectivity and flexibility and, more importantly, embracing a more standardized approach, organizations can create a more equitable workplace where all employees are judged on their skills and work output and have a fair chance of succeeding. 

Birches Group’s five-step approach to achieving equity 

In our first post in this “Equity in Action” series, we introduced Birches Group’s five-step approach to achieving equity in compensation management. We highlighted the urgent need for organizations to move beyond discussions and take concrete action to address inequities in their compensation structures.  

Building on this framework, we examine how this integrated approach can be applied across all HR functions, creating an equitable workplace where every process— from recruitment to succession planning—is grounded in the principle of establishing the equivalent worth of each job within your organization. By minimizing the influence of personal biases at every HR function, we can ensure a level playing field for all staff. 

This integrated approach, as we discussed in the first post, offers a multitude of benefits that can transform your organization: 

  • It reduces bias and increases fairness by relying on objective criteria, thus minimizing the impact of unconscious bias and ensuring all employees are treated equitably.  
  • This approach also enhances transparency and trust. Clear, consistent processes foster transparency and build trust between employees and the organization. 
  • Furthermore, standardized processes streamline HR operations and free up resources for strategic initiatives, improving efficiency and effectiveness.  
  • Finally, objective data offers valuable insights into workforce trends and enables informed, data-driven decision-making. 

However, we understand that bridging the gap between the theoretical ideals of equity and real-world implementation can be challenging. Organizations often encounter obstacles like bias creeping into decision-making despite best intentions, vague criteria making it difficult to assess staff members objectively and consistently, and inconsistent processes leading to unfair treatment. 

To overcome these challenges, we encourage you to conduct an equity assessment and evaluate your current HR policies and practices critically. Ask yourself these questions: 

  • Does the candidate’s skill level determine your starting salaries, or are they influenced by factors like negotiation skills or salary history?  
  • Are your performance reviews based on clear, measurable metrics based on the expectations of the job, or are they prone to subjectivity and bias?  
  • Are your promotion criteria transparent and consistently applied, or are they open to interpretation?  
  • Does your compensation structure reflect the value of each grade level, or are there unexplained pay gaps?  

These are areas where most of the inequities and inconsistencies begin. 

An integrated framework and tool, like Birches Group’s CommunityTM platform, can be especially invaluable.  

It provides standardized processes to ensure consistency and fairness across all HR functions. Additionally, CommunityTM presents clear metrics to deliver objective measures of skills, competencies, and performance.  

By reducing reliance on subjective judgment, your organization can minimize the impact of bias and promote data-driven decision-making. This creates a truly equitable workplace where all employees are empowered to reach their full potential. 

Applying the approach across HR 

Let’s explore how our integrated approach to achieving equity can be applied across various HR functions: 

Recruitment 

Imagine a recruitment process where every decision is rooted in the defined skills profile of the job. This means targeting your recruitment efforts to attract candidates with the specific skills and competencies needed for the role, ensuring a diverse pool of qualified applicants. It also means using standardized assessments to evaluate each candidate’s skills and abilities, eliminating bias and ensuring that hiring decisions are based solely on knowledge and experience.  

Finally, it involves determining starting salaries based on demonstrated skill level within the respective pay range of the job, eliminating the need for salary negotiations and ensuring pay equity from day one. 

Pay movement 

With an integrated approach, pay increases become a transparent and objective process. Salary adjustments are tied to clearly defined skills growth and contributions, ensuring all staff members are rewarded fairly for their development. Clear criteria are established for salary adjustments, such as acquiring new skills, taking on increased responsibilities leading to bigger contributions, reducing the potential for pay gaps, and ensuring that pay decisions are data-driven. 

Learning & development 

Our approach transforms learning & development from a generic offering to a targeted investment in employee growth. It starts with using objective skills assessments to identify individual skill gaps and development needs, enabling personalized learning journeys.  

Then, staff members work on their personal learning & development assignments specifically tailored to address those identified needs either deeper into the role or work toward the next higher grade level, maximizing employee growth and engagement. This fosters a culture of continuous learning & development, where staff are encouraged to acquire new skills and advance their careers.  

Furthermore, our approach promotes shared responsibility between managers and employees for development, with managers actively supporting their team members’ growth by providing/identifying opportunities and staff taking ownership of their learning journey. 

Succession planning 

Organizations can build a strong leadership pipeline by applying an objective lens to succession planning. Standardized criteria assess employees’ readiness for promotion, ensuring that advancement decisions are based on merit and potential, not favoritism.  

Clear succession pathways and policies are established based on skills and competencies, providing staff members with a roadmap for career progression. This cultivates a talented pool of future leaders, ensuring the long-term sustainability of your organization.  

How CommunityTM can support your equity journey   

Putting these principles into practice may seem daunting, but Birches Group’s CommunityTM framework and tool can seamlessly guide your organization through the five-step approach from start to finish. This integrated platform provides the structure and resources you need to operationalize equity across all your HR processes. 

CommunityTM offers a range of solutions designed to support your equity journey: 

  • Centralized skills data. CommunityTM presents a central hub for managing all your skills data, enabling you to create a comprehensive skills inventory for your workforce and track staff skills development over time. This centralized system ensures that everyone is assessed against the same objective criteria. 
  • Objective assessment tools. With built-in assessment tools that utilize the same consistent framework, CommunityTM helps you evaluate skills and competencies objectively, minimizing bias and ensuring fair treatment.  
  • Data-driven insights. CommunityTM generates powerful data-driven insights that inform your decision-making across all HR functions. Identify skill gaps, track pay equity progress, and analyze workforce trends to make informed decisions that promote fairness and transparency. 
  • Support for key HR functions. CommunityTM offers the tools and resources to embed equity into every stage of the employee lifecycle, from recruitment and pay movement to learning & development and succession planning. 

By leveraging the power of CommunityTM, your organization can move beyond theoretical discussions of equity and take concrete action to build a fair workplace. With its integrated approach, objective assessment tools, and data-driven insights, Community™ empowers you to create an organization where every employee can thrive. 

What about performance? 

At this point, you might be wondering: “This all sounds great, but where does performance fit into this approach?” 

While our focus has been on building a foundation of equity through skills and competencies, we understand that performance is still a critical factor in employee development and motivation. Assessing skills and rewarding performance are separate but related pieces of the puzzle in retaining and motivating your workforce.  

Think of it this way: skills represent an individual’s growth in knowledge and experience, while performance reflects how effectively they use those skills to achieve results. Both are essential for a thriving organization. 

CommunityTM addresses this with a robust performance management system that offers a simple but comprehensive view of staff performance. This platform allows you to provide 360° feedback from various internal and external stakeholders. In addition, CommunityTM enables your organization to acknowledge and reward staff for their contributions, celebrating both those who meet expectations and those who exceed them, fostering a culture of appreciation and broad staff motivation.  

It’s important to emphasize that performance should be assessed solely for rewarding achievement. It should not be a factor in determining a staff member’s pay increase or promotion eligibility, as those decisions should be grounded in skills assessment. 

By keeping this distinction, you can ensure that your performance management system serves its purpose: to motivate employees and reward their contributions.  

Get in touch with Birches Group 

Achieving true equity across your HR processes requires a commitment to objectivity, transparency, and a unified approach. It demands a shift from ad-hoc arrangements to standardized processes, from subjective judgments to data-driven decisions. 

Birches Group is your trusted partner in navigating this journey. Our proven five-step approach and the CommunityTM platform provide the framework and tools you need to operationalize equity across your organization. 

Ready to create a workplace where every employee has a fair chance to thrive? Contact Birches Group today. Our team of experts is prepared to offer the guidance and support you need to make equity a reality. 

Carla is a part-time copywriter on our marketing team in Manila. Before shifting to freelance writing in 2020, she worked as a marketing and communications specialist at the offices of EY and Grant Thornton. She has written about HR and career development for Kalibrr.

Follow us on LinkedIn for more content on pay management and HR solutions.

A woman in a polka dot shirt is sitting at a desk, using a laptop, with a cup nearby.

WHY GETTING PAY AND BENEFITS RIGHT IS CRUCIAL FOR NGOs

Written by Bianca Valencia on . Posted in Resources.

Managing a workforce, especially compensation, presents significant challenges for many non-governmental organizations (NGOs). Unlike the private sector, many NGOs trail behind in having an established compensation philosophy and program. This gap hinders the ability of organizations to attract and retain the skilled staff necessary to achieve their mission, particularly in competitive labor markets like the United Kingdom (UK). 

Despite the desire to offer competitive pay and benefits, NGOs—particularly those reliant on government or donor funding—are under scrutiny to demonstrate good value. This kind of scrutiny requires responsible compensation management, not only for core jobs working in head offices but also for program staff operating in the field. Salaries must be set objectively based on the cost of labor rather than ad hoc or solely on the cost of living. 

To overcome this, NGOs must prioritize an integrated compensation approach. Competitive salaries and benefits packages help NGOs attract and retain skilled individuals passionate about their cause. 

This blog post explores the importance of equitable pay and benefits strategies that attract and retain talent, drive success, and maximize your NGO’s impact. 

The competitive NGO landscape

The UK’s NGO sector is highly competitive for talent. Skilled professionals, from program managers to fundraisers, have many organizations to choose from. NGOs must remain competitive, as these professionals are naturally drawn to organizations offering competitive compensation and benefits and demonstrating a strong alignment with their values. 

In this environment, NGOs can’t afford to lag. Pay equity and transparency are not just buzzwords but essential for recruitment and retention. Today’s workforce is increasingly aware of pay disparities and seeks employers who prioritize fair treatment and equal opportunities. Salary benchmarking plays a critical role in demonstrating this commitment. 

To attract and retain skilled talent, NGOs need to base compensation on the cost of labor in the market and benchmark against jobs of equivalent value. This approach ensures competitive salaries that reflect the true value employees bring to the organization. airness but motivates staff to develop their skills and contribute meaningfully. 

The significance of salary surveys

Salary surveys are invaluable for NGOs, ensuring they offer competitive and fair compensation. Such surveys provide objective, comprehensive data on market rates for comparable roles, enabling informed decisions about pay and benefits. Here is why they’re a helpful addition to your HR toolkit: 

  • Objective benchmarking. Salary surveys enable NGOs to compare their compensation packages against jobs of equivalent value in the market, ensuring competitive salaries that attract and retain talent. 
  • Defensible compensation. Data from salary surveys allows NGOs to justify salary decisions to staff, management, and donors, promoting transparency and accountability. 
  • Market insights. Salary surveys provide a broader market view than internal data, offering insights into emerging trends, regional variations, and sector-specific compensation. 
  • Gap analysis. Participating in salary surveys reveals areas where compensation may fall behind, including hiring rates, competitive salaries for specific grade levels, benefits, and more. 
  • Benefits competitiveness. Surveys like those from Birches Group often include data on benefits, allowing NGOs to assess their offerings and make necessary adjustments. 
  • Compliance with market practices. Using salary surveys helps NGOs align with sectoral standards and legal requirements. 
  • Proactive budgeting. Salary surveys help NGOs anticipate salary expenses and plan budgets effectively, ensuring financial sustainability. 
  • Trend analysis. Tracking salary data over time allows NGOs to stay ahead of changing market trends and adjust compensation strategies accordingly. 

Salary surveys provide a comprehensive and objective market view that your organization couldn’t easily obtain independently. They offer insights into gaps between your target position and the market, the competitiveness of your benefits, and adherence to best market practices. Salary surveys help you stay ahead of trends and assist with budgeting for your organization’s biggest expense—salaries. 

Final thoughts

In the NGO sector, getting pay and benefits right is paramount for attracting and retaining individuals who drive meaningful change. Prioritizing compensation allows teams to maximize their impact.

Take the first step: Assess your current compensation program, benchmark against sectoral standards using reliable salary surveys, and seek expert guidance. Birches Group provides NGOs with the most comprehensive compensation and benefits surveys dedicated to the development sector, including accurate and consistent job matching, salary data captured by grade level, and extensive benefits information.

We offer tailored compensation and benefits solutions to help your organization attract, retain, and empower talent worldwide. Contact your representative at Bond to learn how you can participate and access our surveys. Investing in your people is an investment in your mission, ensuring long-term sustainability and effectiveness in addressing critical social challenges.

Carla is a part-time copywriter on our marketing team in Manila. Before shifting to freelance writing in 2020, she worked as a marketing and communications specialist at the offices of EY and Grant Thornton. She has written about HR and career development for Kalibrr.

Follow us on LinkedIn for more content on pay management and HR solutions.

EQUITY IN ACTION: IMPLEMENT FAIR PAY MANAGEMENT MECHANISMS

Written by Noel Madolid on . Posted in Resources.

In pursuing workplace equity, we’ve examined the critical steps: establishing equivalent worth, developing a job grading structure, utilizing comprehensive salary surveys, and implementing a well-defined salary scale. These foundational elements create the framework for fair pay. 

But the journey continues. Transitioning from establishing the framework to actively managing pay is where equity flourishes. 

It’s time to take the final step: implementing fair pay management mechanisms. This ongoing process ensures that your meticulously crafted pay structure remains relevant and equitable long-term. Without equitable management, even the most robust compensation program can falter, leading to pay disparities and inequities. 

This post examines the essential mechanisms for ongoing pay management, empowering your organization to cultivate a genuinely equitable and fair workplace. 

Why traditional pay progression fails to achieve equity 

Pay management mechanisms are the processes and policies that govern how your people move through your established salary ranges. They drive your compensation program, ensuring ongoing equity within your organization. 

However, traditional approaches to pay progression often miss the mark when it comes to fairness. Why? Let’s examine two common methods: 

  • Time-based steps. While clear, predictable, and easy to administer, this approach suffers from a critical flaw: everyone receives an increase regardless of performance. Someone exceeding expectations gets the same raise as someone barely meeting minimum standards. This can be incredibly demotivating for high performers and fails to recognize individual growth. 
  • Pay-for-performance or merit increases. This method aims to reward top performers with higher raises, but it, too, often falls short. Pay increases are frequently too small to truly differentiate meaningfully between performance levels. Additionally, basing salary adjustments solely on annual performance reviews is problematic. Performance can fluctuate year to year, meaning a one-time “good” year can lead to a permanent salary increase, even if performance later declines. 

Both approaches fail to create a truly equitable pay structure, lacking the flexibility and nuance to accurately recognize individual contributions and growth. This can lead to pay gaps, dissatisfaction and, ultimately, a less equitable workplace. 

To create a truly equitable pay system, organizations must move beyond outdated models and explore more objective, transparent, and equitable approaches to pay progression. 

A truly equitable pay management system hinges on transparency and clearly defined criteria for progression. This means establishing a clear and consistent pathway for employees to advance through the salary scale based on objective measures such as skills, competencies, and contributions aligned with their jobs and the organization’s mission. 

Think of it like a roadmap. Every employee should understand the route to progress within their role and have equal opportunity to reach their career goals. This fosters a sense of fairness but motivates staff to develop their skills and contribute meaningfully. 

Developing a system for staff progression through the salary scale 

Creating a transparent and fair system for salary progression is imperative for fostering a culture of equity. Here are key strategies to achieve this: 

Skills-based progression 

Implement a framework that objectively measures staff skills, linking it directly to pay progression. This means clearly defining the skills and competencies required at each level of the salary range and using standardized assessments to measure employee skills against these levels. Be transparent about how acquiring new skills or demonstrating increased expertise translates to salary increases or promotions. This approach ensures that pay progression is tied to tangible growth and development. 

Regular reviews and updates 

The market and your organization are constantly evolving. Regularly review and update your salary structure and progression system to demonstrate a commitment to fair pay. This allows you to maintain market competitiveness, address any internal pay disparities that may arise, and provide opportunities for employees to move through the salary range based on the growth of their skills and the impact of their contributions. 

Benefits of a structured progression system 

But why go to all this effort? Because a well-structured approach to pay movement offers significant benefits for both your staff and your organization. 

  • Increased transparency and trust. Employees understand how pay decisions are made, fostering a sense of fairness and trust in the organization. 
  • Enhanced motivation and engagement. Clear pathways for advancement motivate employees to invest in their development and contribute their best work. 
  • Reduced pay disparities and improved retention. Objective criteria minimize the risk of bias and discrimination in pay decisions, promoting equity and increasing employee satisfaction. 

How Birches Group’s Community™ Skills can help 

Developing and implementing fair pay management mechanisms can be challenging. But your HR team doesn’t have to go on this journey alone. 

At Birches Group, we believe that pay movement should be tied to the development and growth of staff’s skills and experience. As employees gain experience, they develop a deeper understanding of their role and accumulate the skills needed to help them be more effective and produce higher-quality work.  

Birches Group Community™ Skills provides a way to measure this experience. Organizations can use our framework and tool to structure their compensation systems, rewarding employees for growth and development within their roles, rather than solely relying on performance metrics. Organizations can link their compensation administration to the progression of skills in any number of ways, from assessing and setting the appropriate starting salary based purely on candidates’ skill levels during recruitment to managing pay movement within the salary range and tailoring learning and development assignments to guide staff development and career pathing. 

Contact Birches Group today 

Implementing fair pay management mechanisms and a structured progression system is not about ticking boxes. It’s about fostering a workplace where every employee feels valued, recognized, and rewarded fairly. By embracing the five-step approach to workplace equity, your organization can create a culture of transparency, trust, and opportunity. 

We understand that this journey can be complex. That’s why we encourage you to seek guidance from experts who can help you navigate the intricacies of building an equitable compensation program. 

Is your organization ready to achieve workplace equity? Contact Birches Group today. Our team of experienced consultants can provide the expertise and support you need. 

Carla is a part-time copywriter on our marketing team in Manila. Before shifting to freelance writing in 2020, she worked as a marketing and communications specialist at the offices of EY and Grant Thornton. She has written about HR and career development for Kalibrr.

Follow us on LinkedIn for more content on pay management and HR solutions.

Equity in Action: Implement a Salary Scale

EQUITY IN ACTION: IMPLEMENT A SALARY SCALE

Written by Noel Madolid on . Posted in Resources.

Welcome back to our series on workplace equity! In our previous blog posts, we explored the foundational steps toward achieving a fair and equitable work environment, from establishing equivalent worth and developing a grading structure to utilizing salary surveys. We emphasized the importance of transparency and communication in building trust with your staff. 

Now, it’s time to take the next significant step in your equity journey: implementing a salary scale. While establishing clear job grades and salary ranges is essential, it’s only the beginning. A salary scale provides a structured framework for your compensation, ensuring consistent and fair pay across your organization. It acts as a roadmap for staff progression within those ranges, ensuring that growth and compensation are aligned in a way that’s both fair and motivating.  

In this post, we’ll discuss how implementing a well-defined salary scale can be a vital tool in your equity journey. We’ll explore the benefits of having pay ranges, guide you through developing a salary scale that supports your equity goals, and offer practical tips for successful implementation. 

Why a salary scale matters 

The salary scale defines the minimum, midpoint, and maximum pay for each role within an organization. The salary scale is the most important document in human resources, providing valuable insights into the organization’s structure, job grading, and the value placed on different grade levels. The overlap between grades also illustrates how staff can progress through the ranks. 

Think of a salary scale as a roadmap for compensation. This roadmap guides both employers and employees, ensuring everyone understands the organization’s compensation philosophy and policy.  

For employers, a clearly defined salary scale offers numerous advantages, including: 

  1. Budgeting and forecasting. Salary scales facilitate accurate budgeting and forecasting by providing a clear picture of salary costs. This predictability allows for better financial planning and resource allocation. 
  1. Transparency and trust. With clearly defined pay ranges, organizations promote transparency and build trust with their employees. Everyone understands the compensation philosophy and how their pay is determined, reducing the potential for confusion or resentment. 
  1. Legal compliance. Having a salary scale ensures compliance with equal pay regulations and lessens the chances of pay discrimination. By establishing clear criteria for pay, organizations minimize legal risks and promote fair treatment. 
  1. Talent attraction and retention. A competitive salary scale helps to attract talent and retain existing staff. When employees know their employer is ensuring their compensation is fair and competitive, they are more likely to stay with the organization and contribute to its success. 
  1. Pay movement based on skills growth. As staff develop their abilities and expertise, their value and contributions to the organization increase, and their compensation can reflect that growth. This framework ensures fairness and equity by recognizing employees for continuously improving and developing within their roles. 

Salary scales also provide significant value for employees: 

  1. Clarity and understanding. Employees gain a clear understanding of the salary range for their role and how their pay is determined. This transparency fosters trust in the compensation strategy. 
  1. Fairness and equity. A structured salary scale ensures pay is based on objective criteria, such as the equivalent worth of the job (job evaluation) and referencing external labor market conditions (salary benchmarking). This helps eliminate biases and promotes a sense of fairness. 
  1. Career growth. Salary scales provide a roadmap for career progression. Employees can see the potential for salary increases as they gain experience deeper into the range, or take on a higher level of responsibility and scope and advance within the organization. 
  1. Motivation. Knowing their pay is linked to skills growth motivates staff to perform well, seek development opportunities, and improve their capabilities. 
  1. Organizational culture. A structured pay scale provides employees with a sense of security and stability. 

Developing an equitable salary scale 

Developing an effective and equitable salary scale requires careful planning and execution. It involves creating a tool that reflects your organization’s values, ensures internal cohesion, and remains competitive within the labor market. Here are the key steps: 

  1. Establish a job structure. A clear job structure shows how jobs are organized and ranked based on their purpose, scope, and placement within the organization. 
  1. Develop a compensation philosophy. Your compensation philosophy outlines your approach to choosing comparable organizations, setting your desired market position (lead, match, or lag), and benefits package. 
  1. Benchmark salaries against the market. Assess your organization’s competitiveness by benchmarking your jobs against similar grade levels in the labor market. This step involves comparing your internal pay grades and salaries for specific roles with those offered by similar organizations. 
  1. Define your composition and position. Define your target market position and the criteria for selecting your target comparator organizations. 
  1. Tailor job levels. Adopt a tailored approach that reflects expectations around employment and opportunities for each job level. 
  1. Design your compensation package from a ‘total compensation’ perspective. In most markets around the world, especially in developing markets, benefits make up a significant portion of compensation. To truly be competitive in the markets you’re trying to reach, analyze your total compensation package to include cash and in-kind benefits that are common practice in those markets. Consider locally mandated benefits, market practices, and benefits that promote desirable behaviors. 

Implementing and maintaining your salary scale 

Now that you’ve developed your salary scale, the next step is to communicate your analysis to management and prepare to communicate the changes to your staff. 

Laying the foundation 

Before introducing the salary scale, it’s best to establish solid groundwork. Laying the foundation for your salary scale includes taking the following measures: 

  • Secure management buy-in. Clearly articulate the rationale behind having an up-to-date salary scale. Highlight the issues it can address, such as pay inequities, challenges in attracting talent, and potential legal risks. Underscore how the salary scale will contribute to a more equitable and competitive compensation structure, ultimately benefiting the organization as a whole. 
  • Establish a robust job evaluation process. Ensure that your job evaluation process is in place before developing your salary scale, as it provides the basis for slotting jobs accurately within the structure. 
  • Ensure transparency. Openly communicate how the new salary scale will be implemented. Outline the timelines, phasing plans, and any potential impact on existing compensation arrangements to manage expectations.  

Rolling out the scale 

Once the groundwork is laid, the focus shifts to effectively rolling out the new scale and ensuring its smooth integration into your compensation strategy: 

  • Equip managers for effective communication. Managers play an important role in communicating the changes to their teams. Provide them with the necessary resources, such as talking points, FAQs, and training on handling sensitive questions. Doing so will help ensure a smooth transition and minimize potential misunderstandings or concerns. 
  • Link skills growth with salary progression. Clearly define the link between growth in knowledge and experience and salary progression within the scale. Establish transparent expectations and criteria for advancement, ensuring employees understand how their growth in skills can influence their compensation growth. 

Maintaining and reviewing the scale 

Implementing your salary scale is not a “set it and forget it” exercise. Continuous maintenance and review are crucial to ensure its ongoing effectiveness and relevance. This ongoing process includes: 

  • Regular reviews and updates. Markets are dynamic, and your salary scale should be, too. Review and revise your scale annually to stay competitive. Consider factors such as labor market data and industry trends to ensure your compensation remains aligned with the labor market. 
  • Conducting pay equity audits. Regularly conduct pay equity audits to identify and address any potential gaps or inconsistencies within the salary scale. This should be a continuing process to ensure the scale remains fair, effective, and compliant. 

Partner with the experts at Birches Group 

Developing, rolling out, and maintaining your salary scale can be complex. While the tips and best practices outlined above provide a solid starting point, navigating the intricacies of compensation management often requires specialized expertise. This is particularly true when it comes to implementing fair pay management mechanisms, which is the focus of our final blog post in our Equity in Action series. 

Successfully integrating fair pay practices into your compensation strategy calls for a deep understanding of legal frameworks, labor market dynamics, and ethical considerations. This is where partnering with experienced compensation professionals can make all the difference. 

Our team of experts specializes in: 

  • Pay equity audits. We conduct comprehensive audits to identify and address any gender, race, or other pay gaps, ensuring your organization meets legal requirements and promotes fairness. 
  • Salary scale design. We design robust and competitive salary structures tailored to your organization’s needs and market benchmarks. 
  • Compensation strategy consulting: We provide guidance on developing and implementing effective compensation strategies. 

Birches Group’s consultants have years of experience designing salary scales for different types of organizations. Download our comprehensive e-book, Strategy, Structure, and Synthesis, to learn more.  

Ready to create a fair and equitable compensation program? Contact Birches Group today for a strategy consultation. 

Carla is a part-time copywriter on our marketing team in Manila. Before shifting to freelance writing in 2020, she worked as a marketing and communications specialist at the offices of EY and Grant Thornton. She has written about HR and career development for Kalibrr.

Follow us on LinkedIn for more content on pay management and HR solutions.

A group of people sitting around a table in an office.

WHY ORGANIZATIONS SHOULD OUTSOURCE THEIR SALARY SCALE DESIGN

Written by Kai Donesa on . Posted in Resources.

Organizations are beginning to recognize that the key to attracting and retaining top talent hinges heavily on a strategic, fair, and competitive salary scale. Yet, tailoring this structure to your unique needs can be complex.

Do you have the tools to properly analyze labor market data? Can your human resources (HR) team maintain the salary scale annually, in addition to addressing other responsibilities? Is there a way to design and update your salary scale more efficiently? This is where outsourcing is necessary.

Outsourcing the design and maintenance of your salary scale unburdens you and your HR team from this intricate task, allowing you to focus on your core business operations. Handing this responsibility over to more experienced professionals does not only save time; it ensures that your salary scale aligns with your strategic goals, global policies, market trends, and industry standards.

This article discusses why organizations should consider outsourcing the design and maintenance of their salary scale. We will explore how this pragmatic move can help you, from gaining expert advice to ensuring market alignment. If you’ve been second-guessing whether you need to outsource your salary scale design, our insights might be what you need to make an informed decision.

Understanding salary scale design

Your salary scale is the single most important document in HR. The structure determines how much an employee will be paid based on their role, their value for experience at each grade level, and the difference between one grade level to the next. It tells your stakeholders everything they need to know about your organization, including:

  • How you position yourself in the market
  • What value you place on your jobs
  • How you manage relationships across jobs
  • What are the possible career progressions
  • Where you stand on equity and transparency

A well-balanced salary scale is crucial for your people to work efficiently and achieve team cohesion. Your salary scale drives all other HR programs, including recruitment, staff retention, promotion, and career development.

Designing the scale is not only about deciding how much to pay an employee or listing pay grades. It is driven by building a fair and equitable compensation structure that shows how you attract and retain talent, as well as motivate staff. It involves balancing internal considerations and team dynamics with the external market.

However, designing and updating your salary scale requires a deep understanding of your business strategy, a thorough knowledge of the labor market, and keen insight into the motivations and expectations of staff. These tasks demand a high level of skill, expertise, and experience.

Why it’s essential to have a well-designed salary scale

A well-designed salary scale establishes a framework for determining staff compensation and sets the standard for pay equity within your organization. It also helps ensure employees are rewarded fairly, boosting morale and motivation.

Your salary scale also serves as a roadmap for career progression, giving staff a clear idea of what they can expect as they advance. This transparency can help foster trust and loyalty among staff, leading to increased job satisfaction and lower turnover rates.

Further, a well-designed and updated salary scale can help your organization attract and retain top talent. By offering competitive salaries in line with market rates, you can position your organization as an employer of choice.

Common challenges in designing a salary scale

Designing a salary scale is not without its challenges, though. One of the fundamental issues is determining the appropriate pay range for each grade level within your organization. This requires a thorough understanding of the job market and the ability to assess the value of each level accurately, carefully balancing your organization’s workforce needs and overall budget.

Another challenge is ensuring pay equity. This involves making sure employees are paid fairly for their work. Achieving pay equity can be complicated, especially in large organizations with a diverse workforce across labor markets.

Keeping the salary scale up to date is also a concern. The job market constantly evolves, and the value of specific roles can change rapidly. The salary scale must be updated every year to reflect market trends.

The benefits of outsourcing salary scale design

Outsourcing the design of your salary scale offers several advantages:

  1. First, it frees up valuable time and resources. Designing a salary scale requires a significant amount of time and expertise. By outsourcing this task, your HR team can focus on other vital projects, such as employee engagement and talent development.
  2. Second, outsourcing gives you access to expert knowledge and insights. An HR consultancy firm like Birches Group has a deeper understanding of labor markets across continents. Additionally, firms such as ours can share accurate and timely information about salary trends and benchmarks.
  3. Finally, outsourcing ensures fairness and objectivity. An external firm can design a salary scale free of internal biases or conflicts of interest.

Case study: Elizabeth Glaser Pediatric AIDS Foundation

To illustrate the benefits of outsourcing your salary scale design and maintenance, let’s consider the case of the Elizabeth Glaser Pediatric AIDS Foundation (EGPAF), a nonprofit organization supporting activities in 19 countries. EGPAF had a centralized salary system but needed to ensure its salary scales kept up with the market, especially in Africa.

EGPAF tapped us to design its salary scale over several years. Doing so refined the nonprofit’s salary scales with a view closer to the local setting. We then looked at each African location, improving EGPAF’s pay structures and systems based on our NGO Surveys. Based on their budget, we developed three different salary scale options for each country.

As a result, EGPAF can now:

  • Name which comparators are relevant to them based on consistent comparator criteria developed for their salary scale review, and which scale design approach best addressed its internal compensation issues, all while staying within budget.
  • Get a more precise snapshot of the labor market through our salary survey data.
  • Anticipate and be better equipped when sudden changes in the market occur.

This case illustrates the significant benefits that can be gained from outsourcing your salary scale design.

How Birches Group can help you design and update your salary scale

Creating and maintaining a salary scale is a technical and creative process best left to specialists. If you’re considering developing or updating your organization’s salary scale, we at Birches Group are here to help. With our team of experienced professionals, we can provide salary scale options tailored to your needs.

We have extensive expertise in adapting or creating salary structures through our work with many clients from the public and private sectors. We believe proper salary scale design must be tailored to your needs and culture, as well as your compensation philosophy, market position, and budget. A well-designed salary scale must also align with the local market and adhere to corporate policy and compensation goals.

If you’re ready to learn more about how we can design and maintain your salary scale, contact us today.

Carla is a part-time copywriter in our marketing team in Manila. Before shifting to freelance writing in 2020, she worked as a marketing and communications specialist at the offices of EY and Grant Thornton. She has written about HR and career development for Kalibrr. 

Follow us on our LinkedIn for more content on pay management and HR solutions.

BUILDING YOUR SCALE: IMPLENTING YOUR NEW SCALE

Written by Kai Donesa on . Posted in Resources.

Now that your salary scale and benefits package is ready, the final step is implementing your new scale and communicating the changes to your teams. Equipped with your analysis and overall cost implications against your budget, you will now need to secure the necessary approval from management.

When seeking approval, begin by presenting any existing issues with the current salary scale and the challenges your salaries are facing against the external market. Take management through your process when you built your new salary scale, making sure to highlight:

  • The chosen salary survey you used as a basis
  • Your chosen set of target comparators that met your criteria
  • The difference of your existing salaries against your target market position
  • The steps you have taken to address the current issues and build future capacity
  • The overall cost

Finally, you also need to present to management your implementation plan and the timeframe that it will require, so they can assess the entire impact of the new scale.

Once approval has been granted, the next step is communicating the changes to staff. This is a crucial process because you will need to equip your managers with the right information for them to relay later to each of their teams or units. When discussing the changes with your staff, keep these in mind:

  • Discuss the work that went into building the salary scale and be clear on the company policy that supports the steps you have taken. This will ensure that your managers will be ready to answer any questions or reactions their staff may have.
  • Be clear about your implementation plan, what staff can expect, and when. This way, you can manage everyone’s expectations and hopefully have them feel excited about the changes that are soon to take place.

With the steps we have shared on implementing your new scale, we hope this has provided you with the insight you need to get started in designing your own pay structure. Birches Group is always ready to help organizations create a salary scale that will work for them. Contact us to learn more.

Want to know if your existing compensation practices have the elements of a good compensation program or if there are areas that could use some improvement? Take our quick Compensation Program Assessment Quiz to know your score!

Bianca manages our Marketing Team in Manila. She crafts messaging around Community™ concepts and develops promotional campaigns answering why Community™ should be each organization’s preferred solution, focusing on its simplicity and integrated approach. She has held various roles within Birches Group since 2009, starting as a Compensation Analyst and worked her way to Compensation Team Lead, and Training Program Services Manager. In addition to her current role in marketing and communications, she represents Birches Group in international HR conferences with private sector audiences.

Follow us on our LinkedIn for more content on pay management and HR solutions.

BUILDING YOUR SALARY SCALE: ADJUSTING YOUR SCALE

Written by Kai Donesa on . Posted in Resources.

Now that you’ve created your salary scale and examined your benefits package; the next step is adjusting your scale. Refining your scale will be a trial and error process until you get as close to your target as possible. There are several factors that will affect the impact of your scale, both externally and internally, so it is crucial to keep these in mind every step of the way.

When we think about external factors that affect the impact of your salary scale, factors such as average market movement, your budget, the number of incumbents per grade level in your organization, as well as the overall cost all need to be considered. When you start allocating adjustments for each grade level in your scale, using the average market movement and your budget, you can start adjusting your scale’s minimums and maximums, while keeping the number of incumbents per grade level in mind. Once you have gotten as close to your target market position as possible, check if your adjustments are all within budget. If not, keep adjusting and tweak where necessary.

While adjusting your pay ranges, you also want to keep in mind the issues that your existing salary scale has and how your changes will best address them. Are your hiring rates competitive at the job levels where you need more capacity? Do any of your existing staff fall below your current hiring rates? Similarly, do you have staff that are currently paid beyond the maximum salaries of their grade level? Do you make use of your salary ranges per grade level or do you find many of your staff clustered in certain points in each grade? Remember, adjusting your salary scale is not simply about updating salaries following market movement. It is also about making corrections where you know there are inefficiencies in the current pay structure.

Just as important as reaching your target market position and being competitive externally, is your team’s internal cohesion. Once you have reached your desired salary scale results, give it another look to see if everything makes sense. Pay close attention to your internal parameters, such as the progression from one grade level to the next, and see if the overlaps are reasonable. Examine your spans – the difference between your minimum and maximum salaries – as well and see if they align with the nature of each job level within your organization. Also, you will need to see how each of the adjustments you made will affect staff at every grade level. Checking for fair internal cohesion will ensure strong staff engagement to which they can tailor their development and build their careers over time.

Designing and refining salary scales is both a technical exercise and a sensitive one. As managers in human resources, we must realize that without an efficient salary structure in place, along with a solid job structure, achieving a strong engaged workforce will always be a challenge. And while we know that the salaries we set will not always make everyone happy – someone will always want higher pay, someone will challenge your chosen set of target comparators, and perhaps ask why they cannot have more benefits – what is important is making sure that the policies that went behind designing the salary scale is clear and communicated to staff. To learn more about how Birches Group can help you design a salary scale fit for your organization’s needs, contact us today.

Want to know if your existing compensation practices have the elements of a good compensation program or if there are areas that could use some improvement? Take our quick Compensation Program Assessment Quiz to know your score!

Bianca manages our Marketing Team in Manila. She crafts messaging around Community™ concepts and develops promotional campaigns answering why Community™ should be each organization’s preferred solution, focusing on its simplicity and integrated approach. She has held various roles within Birches Group since 2009, starting as a Compensation Analyst and worked her way to Compensation Team Lead, and Training Program Services Manager. In addition to her current role in marketing and communications, she represents Birches Group in international HR conferences with private sector audiences.

Follow us on our LinkedIn for more content on pay management and HR solutions.

BUILDING YOUR SALARY SCALE: ANALYZING BENEFITS

Written by Kai Donesa on . Posted in Resources.

Analyzing your benefits package is a step that can’t be missed. In many labor markets around the world, benefits are an essential part of total compensation. Particularly in developing markets, some benefits are mandatory, others may be cultural, and some given to address certain realities on the ground. Whether you are a local organization or an international one, it is essential to have a policy that aligns with your market’s local conditions.

Additionally, benefits are also an important part of a company’s Employment Value Proposition (EVP). Determining which benefits your company provides, the frequency it is provided, and grade levels eligible to receive them can be used a strategy to attract and retain talent, showcase company culture, and be seen as an employer of choice.

Once you have aligned your total compensation against the market, designing your benefits package will begin by ‘backing out’ your benefits to arrive at just base salary. From there, you can assess which benefits to keep and maintain, and which ones to change.

When examining your benefits package, here are three things we suggest you keep in mind:

  • What benefits are considered mandatory in your market? – different countries have different mandatory benefits. Some countries have mandatory bonuses on top of base salary, others may have mandatory housing or transportation allowances, while others have government-mandated health and pension contributions. As an employer, you will need to follow what is prescribed by law, especially if you are an international organization.
  • What benefits are common practice in your market? – knowing which benefits are commonly provided by most employers in your market can also help when designing your benefits package. Of course, it is not necessary to follow every single benefit provided. But those that are given by majority of the companies could be considered and examined further against your budget and policy.
  • What benefits are considered tax-advantageous to your staff? – depending on your market, some benefits can be considered taxable and others non-taxable. When thinking about benefits, employers can provide contributions or cash benefits that do not trigger a tax deduction from staff or maximize its non-taxable portion as much as possible.

Further, when designing your benefits package, employers also need to think about the grade levels that each benefit will apply to. Unless it is mandatory, not all benefits need to be provided to all grade levels and in the same manner. There are some benefits that are given to certain grade levels due to the nature of their jobs. Incentive-based benefits and representational benefits are more common for roles in managerial levels, while cash allowances and transportation benefits are more commonly provided to general and process-based grade levels.

Benefits can also be used by employers to encourage desirable behaviors from their staff. A classic example is using performance bonuses to reward achievement and a job well done at the end of the performance year. Another is the use of loans, seniority allowances, or even company-sponsored savings plans to promote staff retention. Sometimes, companies also hold activities that foster workplace culture among their employees, from team lunches, happy hour, to corporate social responsibility events. In our many years of conducting salary surveys and collecting data from employers in over 150 countries, we have certainly seen a lot of creativity from employers when using benefits that highlight their unique company culture.

When analyzing your benefits, we must remember that, in the end, benefits are cheaper than salaries. Base salary, bonuses, and allowances all come from the same internal budget, so every dollar that goes into providing more benefits will take away from the budget for other components of your staff’s employment package, such as pension and salary increases.

Birches Group can help your organization design a benefits package that aligns with your policy while meeting local conditions. Contact us to get started.

Want to know if your existing compensation practices have the elements of a good compensation program or if there are areas that could use some improvement? Take our quick Compensation Program Assessment Quiz to know your score!

Bianca manages our Marketing Team in Manila. She crafts messaging around Community™ concepts and develops promotional campaigns answering why Community™ should be each organization’s preferred solution, focusing on its simplicity and integrated approach. She has held various roles within Birches Group since 2009, starting as a Compensation Analyst and worked her way to Compensation Team Lead, and Training Program Services Manager. In addition to her current role in marketing and communications, she represents Birches Group in international HR conferences with private sector audiences.

Follow us on our LinkedIn for more content on pay management and HR solutions.